I just saw the above listing on ebay, where the seller grades this book at VF, even while acknowledging the "small tear" in the corner.
In the Overstreet Grading Guide, a G/VG grade calls for no larger than a 1/2 inch corner tear, while the one shown is 1 inch. Even allowing that the rest of the book is otherwise in decent shape, that only qualifies for a "plus" grading increment, or, in this case a bump up to VG-.
That is how I would list it, if I had it in my store. Anybody else have thoughts on this?